Do You Need Years to Experience Emptiness, and Can You Move During Meditation?
A reader recently asked me two questions about mindfulness meditation.
The first was about experiences of emptiness, or more accurately, a relative sense of emptiness, spaciousness, or reduced sensation.
Do you have to practice for a very long time before something like that can happen?
The second question was more practical:
Are you allowed to move during seated meditation?
I think both questions are worth answering, because they touch on something important. Meditation does have methods and general principles, but people are also different. There is no single timeline, and there is no need to turn practice into another form of perfectionism.
You may not need years to experience spaciousness
The honest answer is that it depends.
People have different natural abilities.
We can see this clearly in ordinary life. Some children seem naturally good at mathematics. Some have a strong feeling for language. Some are naturally athletic. It is almost as if everyone begins life with different points already placed on different branches of a skill tree.
I think spiritual practice can be like that too.
If you believe in past lives, you might say that someone practiced before and therefore finds meditation easier in this life. If you do not believe that, you can simply call it natural aptitude. Either way, the practical point is the same.
Before you begin, you do not really know what your aptitude is.
So you also do not know how long it will take before you experience something deeper.
My suggestion is simple: practice honestly and remain open.
Do not tell yourself, “This is impossible for me,” or “I probably need twenty years before anything happens.” That belief may itself become a kind of obstacle.
Something may happen sooner than you expect.
Sometimes beginners even have what people call beginner’s luck. They may sit down and suddenly feel that the body has become very quiet, that part of the body has disappeared, or that the whole visual field has become dark and spacious.
They may not think much of it because nobody has explained what it is.
But that may already be a small experience of spaciousness or reduced sensory activity.
It is not necessarily the absolute emptiness described in Buddhist philosophy. We should not exaggerate it. But it may still be a real shift from our normal, solid way of experiencing the body and the world.
Some practices may point toward emptiness more directly
Although there is no guaranteed timeline, some techniques may make spacious experiences more accessible.
One is to close your eyes and look at the gray-black visual field behind the eyelids.
Do not stare too hard. Just look naturally.
You may see darkness, vague light, changing patterns, or a few points of brightness. Then notice the edges of this visual field.
Where does it end?
You may find that the boundary is unclear. It can feel much larger than expected, almost without a definite edge.
If thoughts arise, you do not need to fight them. Just return to that dark visual field.
You can even hold a gentle willingness to let go of your usual sense of yourself and rest in that space.
For some people, staying with this may create a sense that the ordinary world has faded into the background. There may be a feeling of openness or emptiness.
Another method is to work with areas of the body that have very little sensation.
For example, you might notice the earlobes, the nose, the forehead, or the toes. Different people will find different places.
You can rest attention on one relatively quiet area for a few seconds, then move to another. You may also include the sense of relaxation during the exhale.
The attention is changing locations, but each time it settles on an area with very little sensory information.
As you become more sensitive to this quietness, you may begin to notice other low-sensation areas. Sometimes the body can gradually feel less dense. At a deeper level, the whole body may feel very still, vague, or spacious.
Again, I would not call this the final realization of emptiness.
But it points in that direction.
And time does matter. Ten minutes may give you a taste. Twenty or thirty minutes may allow the experience to deepen. If thirty minutes feels impossible, start with ten. When practice becomes more interesting and you begin to have clearer experiences, you may naturally want to sit longer.
Why people are often told not to move
Now let’s talk about movement.
Usually, meditation instructions encourage you not to move too much.
There is a reason for that.
A lot of movement during meditation does not come from a real physical need. It comes from restlessness, impatience, boredom, or resistance.
The body wants to move because the mind does not want to stay with what is happening.
If you remain still, the stillness of the body can help reveal a deeper stillness in the mind.
The heart of the mind, you might say, is not actually moving, even though thoughts and emotions are moving on the surface. By keeping the body still, we gradually become more sensitive to that deeper stability.
Stillness also teaches us something about impermanence.
An itch appears.
A pain appears.
Restlessness appears.
If you do not move immediately, you may notice that the sensation changes. It may weaken, move to another place, transform, or disappear.
That can be a very useful lesson.
It shows you that not every unpleasant experience needs an immediate reaction.
The same principle can later help in daily life. Something bothers you, and instead of instantly acting, arguing, or escaping, you observe it for a while. Then you discover that it changes on its own.
But stillness should not become self-harm
At the same time, not moving should not become an obsession.
I once knew someone who was very perfectionistic. During a retreat, he sat cross-legged without moving for around three hours. He later injured himself, and for years afterward that area of his body would hurt when the weather changed.
That is not wise practice.
If you believe staying still may injure you, adjust your posture.
The key is to move consciously.
There is a big difference between moving automatically and moving with awareness.
Imagine someone shaking their leg without noticing. Maybe the movement comes from restlessness.
But if that person deliberately observes every sensation involved in shaking the leg, then it becomes a meditation on movement. They may notice the muscles contracting, the pressure changing, and the rhythm of the leg.
And sometimes, once the movement becomes fully conscious, the urge to continue disappears.
That is quite interesting.
Awareness changes the experience.
So if your leg is slightly sore, you may stay still a little longer and observe it. You do not have to move at the first sign of discomfort.
But if the pain becomes too strong, feels dangerous, or may cause injury, then move.
Change your leg position. Straighten the knee. Adjust the body.
Just do it slowly and consciously.
Feel the intention to move.
Feel the movement itself.
Feel the body settling into the new posture.
Then continue meditating.
The point is awareness, not perfection
So, do you need to practice for many years before experiencing spaciousness?
Not necessarily.
People are different, and some practices may point in that direction more directly. Stay open, practice sincerely, and do not decide in advance what you can or cannot experience.
And can you move during meditation?
Yes.
Stillness is valuable because it trains patience, reveals impermanence, and helps the mind settle. But stillness should not become another rigid standard.
If you can remain still safely, stay a little longer and observe.
If you genuinely need to move, move with awareness.
The goal is not to become a statue.
The goal is to become more conscious.
I appreciate you taking the time to read this.
If you’re interested in exploring how mindfulness can support daily life, not just on the cushion, but in ordinary moments, I’d be happy to have you here.
Please subscribe and join me.